In this particular case, Daniel Ellsberg, stole classified information, copied them, and released them to The New York Times to be published. They were called "The Pentagon Papers." The Court ordered a per curiam and the case was brought to the Supreme Court where 6 justices concurred with the right of the 1st and 14th Amendment and 3 dissented.
This case was being argued under the pretense that the First Amendment of free speech and the Fourteenth Amendment of due process were in place rightfully. These justices believed that the information should be accessed to the public and even the government withholding a publication corporation during the period of this trial is unlawful. This is why Justice Douglas believed that there was no right that could withhold the press from publishing these papers, and by doing so to the Times is illegal. I side with the dissenters. I believe that the fundamental wrong doing is that Ellsberg stole these papers in the beginning from national security of the Executive branch. There has to be a reason why these papers would be kept in secret, or else the government would have already let the information loose. Reasons could include the protection of the safety, prosperity, and well-being of the nation as a whole. These papers could also incite unnecessary violence among the people.
Here is some more information about the case, and also the aftermath that concluded this case.
While I personally believe that this case should have been more delicately handled by considering possible public reaction. The aftermath was not hurtful towards the government as it could have been. By letting the newspaper corporation to publish these papers, the government is letting publishers know that their freedom of expressing speech is protected.
Showing posts with label Court Cases. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Court Cases. Show all posts
Sunday, April 24, 2011
Gitlow v. New York (1925)
Benjamin Gitlow was charged because he was inciting ways to overthrow the American government with two of his published books based off of Marx and Engels' Communist Manifesto. When appealed to the Supreme Court, it decided 7 to 2 for the conviction of Gitlow. The court justices believe that although citizens do have the right of the First Amendment, the right of speech, in this particular case, it was for an abusive manner.
The court made a correct decision in this case because it insured the safety of the people of the United States. While free speech is an important right to all of us, if the activity in doing so can potentially cause harm or incite violence toward the society or the government, then I believe it is necessary for each and every state to hold responsibility to judge upon these potential criminals as soon as possible.
Here I have a review of the whole court, which includes those who agreed and dissented in this particular case.
While is is proper to have the right to express particular opinions, even if it is against the "America" ideal, one must limit the emotional content that is being expressed to the public. The government has the right to put down and potential unlawful usage of the freedom of speech in order to preserve public image, morality, and safety.
The court made a correct decision in this case because it insured the safety of the people of the United States. While free speech is an important right to all of us, if the activity in doing so can potentially cause harm or incite violence toward the society or the government, then I believe it is necessary for each and every state to hold responsibility to judge upon these potential criminals as soon as possible.
Here I have a review of the whole court, which includes those who agreed and dissented in this particular case.
While is is proper to have the right to express particular opinions, even if it is against the "America" ideal, one must limit the emotional content that is being expressed to the public. The government has the right to put down and potential unlawful usage of the freedom of speech in order to preserve public image, morality, and safety.
Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas (1954)
This particular case was another corner stone to the forming of the United States we know today. This case represents a set of cases that denied black students from going to the same school facilities as white students. The former reason was that the educational system can be "separate, but equal." With the help of Chief Justice Earl Warren, he persuaded the court that having facilities that separate two different races because of their skin color inherently means that they are not equal. With the backing of the Fourteenth Amendment, this court case got rid of segregated schools.
This decision had to be done in order to move a step towards a less racial nation. When there is enough evidence in our nation that proves that the education facilities of both black and white school are not equal, then revision must be made. When these schools separate people by race, they are also morally segregated due to the idea that they are inferior and by the evidence of having smaller schoolrooms, less supplies, and bad learning conditions.
Chief Justice Earl Warren took the right and a daring step to change history. He went through the words of the constitution one by one, especially that of the Fourteenth Amendment and it still went back to the "separate, but equal" clause. This phrase has indefinitely changed the rights of people of all ethnic origins.
This decision had to be done in order to move a step towards a less racial nation. When there is enough evidence in our nation that proves that the education facilities of both black and white school are not equal, then revision must be made. When these schools separate people by race, they are also morally segregated due to the idea that they are inferior and by the evidence of having smaller schoolrooms, less supplies, and bad learning conditions.
Chief Justice Earl Warren took the right and a daring step to change history. He went through the words of the constitution one by one, especially that of the Fourteenth Amendment and it still went back to the "separate, but equal" clause. This phrase has indefinitely changed the rights of people of all ethnic origins.
Gideon v. Wainwright (1963)
In this case, Clarence Earl Gideon was arrested in Florida because he had the intent of burglary. He was put into trial at court but was too poor to afford his own attorney because at that time in Florida, only those who have capital cases were appointed attorneys. Being brought to the Supreme court, Justice Black used court cases Betts v. Brady and Powell v. Alabama to declare that those who are pressed with criminal activity, and are too poor to afford free counsel, must be provided with an attorney or it is illegal.
This case basically provided everybody, even criminals caught red-handed, a "fair trial" in courts around the nation. Whether there is obvious evidence or not to dictate whether the offender is guilty or not is up to the judge, but for each trial, the offender must have an attorney provided to them if they are too poor to afford one. I believe this was right of Justice Black to decide this because it gave more support to the face that courts in America are fair for everyone, regardless of reason.
The free right to counsel provided all citizens, good or bad, the help of a trained professional of the law. Without any help at all, an amateur could never win a case if he or she has no training in law. By giving everyone the fair help of an attorney, the United States can uphold the fact that it provides everyone the same chance to hold their own in every case.
This case basically provided everybody, even criminals caught red-handed, a "fair trial" in courts around the nation. Whether there is obvious evidence or not to dictate whether the offender is guilty or not is up to the judge, but for each trial, the offender must have an attorney provided to them if they are too poor to afford one. I believe this was right of Justice Black to decide this because it gave more support to the face that courts in America are fair for everyone, regardless of reason.
The free right to counsel provided all citizens, good or bad, the help of a trained professional of the law. Without any help at all, an amateur could never win a case if he or she has no training in law. By giving everyone the fair help of an attorney, the United States can uphold the fact that it provides everyone the same chance to hold their own in every case.
Friday, April 22, 2011
Miranda v. Arizona (1966)
Ernesto Miranda was charged of rape and kidnapping. He was taken into the police station and interrogated without being told that he had a right to get an attorney or a right to remain silent. He was forced to write a confession through pressure and found guilty by state court. An appeal to the Supreme Court in 1966 was approved at a 5 to 4 majority against his conviction, led by Chief Justice Earl Warren. Warren stated that those under interrogation must have these two basic rights given to them.
These regulations and statements by Chief Justice Warren is higher respected in today's society. If any police officer does not say that an offender has the right to remain silent or the right to get an attorney, it is constitutionally illegal. This leads to the fact that some police stations may be questionable of the ways they conduct themselves. Not all statements given to the public by possible convicts should be believed to be the truth. I believe everyone should learn from this case because nobody really knows what goes on inside an interrogation room everywhere and the suspect may be treated to physical if not high degrees of psychological pain.
By completing these two tasks in order for a correct judgement on the suspect's response, many innocent people will not be forced to life in prison. While this system may give those who are guilty a chance to escape their crime, I believe it's more important to value the lives of the innocent first, then deal with those who can be convicted if there is significant evidence.
These regulations and statements by Chief Justice Warren is higher respected in today's society. If any police officer does not say that an offender has the right to remain silent or the right to get an attorney, it is constitutionally illegal. This leads to the fact that some police stations may be questionable of the ways they conduct themselves. Not all statements given to the public by possible convicts should be believed to be the truth. I believe everyone should learn from this case because nobody really knows what goes on inside an interrogation room everywhere and the suspect may be treated to physical if not high degrees of psychological pain.
By completing these two tasks in order for a correct judgement on the suspect's response, many innocent people will not be forced to life in prison. While this system may give those who are guilty a chance to escape their crime, I believe it's more important to value the lives of the innocent first, then deal with those who can be convicted if there is significant evidence.
Thursday, April 21, 2011
Regents of the University of California v. Bakke (1978)
In this case, Applicant Alan Bakke was declined admission to the University of California at Davis. The problem was that he had lower science grade point than the average white applicants but significantly higher aptitude tests. This was for his application to the Medical School of the University, which had a separate admissions process that separated the regular "white" students and those who are minorities or have disadvantages. When brought to the state court, the court ruled in favor of Bakke and ordered his admittance. The University then appealed to the Supreme Court and they ruled a 5 to 4 majority for Bakke stating the violation of the 14th Amendment as their backing.
As I was an applicant to the medical field for UC Davis as well, I believe it was ridiculous for the University to have placed this restriction of applicants based on race and color. Although the standards have already risen today to a point where only the best of batch are able to get in, there is still no real distinction between whether they are accepting students based solely on their academic performance. While it's true that the program does not exist, the rubric for each individual student may be different in the Acceptors' minds.
Here is a description of the case and differing opinions about the case.
Eliminating the Affirmative Action process was definitely a step in the right direction. If we, as a society, were to put up quotas in order to limit certain amount of highly qualified applicants to claim that we want to diversify the campus, then that means talented and highly motivated students will not be able to expand their horizons and further their development intellectually. It is morally positive that a University might want to help the acceptance of the disabled, but this case proved that it's more about the ethnic races of our nation.
As I was an applicant to the medical field for UC Davis as well, I believe it was ridiculous for the University to have placed this restriction of applicants based on race and color. Although the standards have already risen today to a point where only the best of batch are able to get in, there is still no real distinction between whether they are accepting students based solely on their academic performance. While it's true that the program does not exist, the rubric for each individual student may be different in the Acceptors' minds.
Here is a description of the case and differing opinions about the case.
Eliminating the Affirmative Action process was definitely a step in the right direction. If we, as a society, were to put up quotas in order to limit certain amount of highly qualified applicants to claim that we want to diversify the campus, then that means talented and highly motivated students will not be able to expand their horizons and further their development intellectually. It is morally positive that a University might want to help the acceptance of the disabled, but this case proved that it's more about the ethnic races of our nation.
Monday, April 18, 2011
Miller v. California (1973)
In 1973, Miller was charged of publicly advertising his own explicit sexual and adult books. Charged by the State of California, Miller's case was brought to the Supreme Court and with the help of Chief Justice Warren Burger, decided a 5 to 4 vote in California's favor.
I believe that the decision made by the Supreme Court was a step in the right direction. We, as older citizens in our community, should be conscious of the mature material that can be exposed too early to the youth. In order to fix small loopholes in our system that might make a case, such as this one, occur again, Chief Justice Warren Burger helped create three new Guidelines
1. would the average person, "applying contemporary community standard," find that a work, when viewed as a whole appealed to "prurient interest"?
2. does the work depict or describe certain specifically defined sexual conduct in a patently offensive way?
3. does the work lack "serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value"?
>Click Here< This shows another brief summary of the case in an organized manner
These new guidelines are absolutely necessary in today's America. Passing illicit material to those who have no intention or do not want to read or see the material is completely unorthodox. Not considering the families with children, it could be highly offensive to individuals' religion or personal morals.
I believe that the decision made by the Supreme Court was a step in the right direction. We, as older citizens in our community, should be conscious of the mature material that can be exposed too early to the youth. In order to fix small loopholes in our system that might make a case, such as this one, occur again, Chief Justice Warren Burger helped create three new Guidelines
1. would the average person, "applying contemporary community standard," find that a work, when viewed as a whole appealed to "prurient interest"?
2. does the work depict or describe certain specifically defined sexual conduct in a patently offensive way?
3. does the work lack "serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value"?
>Click Here< This shows another brief summary of the case in an organized manner
These new guidelines are absolutely necessary in today's America. Passing illicit material to those who have no intention or do not want to read or see the material is completely unorthodox. Not considering the families with children, it could be highly offensive to individuals' religion or personal morals.
Plessy v. Ferguson (1896)
Plessy was a man who was 1/8 black and decided to sit in the white section of a train. When asked to hand his seat over to a white passenger, he refused and got arrested. Ferguson, the state judge of Louisiana, charged him to be imprison. This decision was agreed by the Supreme Court.
In this court case, Justice Harlan kept his dissent strictly to what he thought Louisiana meant. He believed that the purpose of this law was for the whites and the blacks to "keep to themselves while traveling in railroad passenger coaches." I believe the purpose of "separate but equal" was just an excuse for dissenters to pass federal opinion by putting in equal when in fact being separate "coaches" cannot merely mean equal when the quality of the each separate coach so blatantly unequal. Harlan even claims that the purpose was to give equal accommodation, but with so much evidence all over the nation that black schools and transits are in poorer condition, the claim is unreliable.
Although Justice John Harlan wanted to clarify that the case was not simply a matter of separating two races apart on a train, the majority opinion thought otherwise. This case helped bring tension to this issue of "separate but equal" leading up to the Brown v Board of Education in Topeka Kansas case.
In this court case, Justice Harlan kept his dissent strictly to what he thought Louisiana meant. He believed that the purpose of this law was for the whites and the blacks to "keep to themselves while traveling in railroad passenger coaches." I believe the purpose of "separate but equal" was just an excuse for dissenters to pass federal opinion by putting in equal when in fact being separate "coaches" cannot merely mean equal when the quality of the each separate coach so blatantly unequal. Harlan even claims that the purpose was to give equal accommodation, but with so much evidence all over the nation that black schools and transits are in poorer condition, the claim is unreliable.
Although Justice John Harlan wanted to clarify that the case was not simply a matter of separating two races apart on a train, the majority opinion thought otherwise. This case helped bring tension to this issue of "separate but equal" leading up to the Brown v Board of Education in Topeka Kansas case.
United States v. Nixon (1974)
In this court case, President Nixon was charged of illegally taking and deleting tapes in the Watergate Scandal. Although he claimed executive power, Nixon was overturned by the court and forced to resign.
I believe that the Supreme court had carefully and correctly decided when they believe that President Nixon's defending statement is insufficient. Although it may have been different if Nixon had declared his executive powers against the court in order to protect the "military, diplomatic or sensitive national security secrets..." However, only claiming that the executive privilege will protect his own individual rights seems only to be a selfish reason. Furthermore, by doing so, Nixon is arousing suspicion that he is the culprit. If he really was innocent, he would have no problem surrendering the tapes.
This is a video of Nixon during his resignation video for the public. You can hear him avoiding certain praises in order to make the situation lighter than it actually is.
This court primary proved to the people of the nation that the President does not have the ultimate say and overall power. It symbolizes the checks and balances system in the United States of America.
I believe that the Supreme court had carefully and correctly decided when they believe that President Nixon's defending statement is insufficient. Although it may have been different if Nixon had declared his executive powers against the court in order to protect the "military, diplomatic or sensitive national security secrets..." However, only claiming that the executive privilege will protect his own individual rights seems only to be a selfish reason. Furthermore, by doing so, Nixon is arousing suspicion that he is the culprit. If he really was innocent, he would have no problem surrendering the tapes.
This is a video of Nixon during his resignation video for the public. You can hear him avoiding certain praises in order to make the situation lighter than it actually is.
This court primary proved to the people of the nation that the President does not have the ultimate say and overall power. It symbolizes the checks and balances system in the United States of America.
Roe v. Wade (1973)
In 1973, the Supreme Court decided in a 7 to 2 vote for Roe's case. She was an unmarried pregnant woman who wanted to get an abortion in the state of Texas. Texas had prohibited abortion unless the mother's life is in danger.
Obviously, the choice should be available to mothers if their lives are in danger. However, the state argues against this choice because certain states are generally geared toward one end of the political party spectrum. They want to maintain their ideals in the courts as well as hold down state values that have long prospered in that particular state.
Roe v. Wade has to be one of the cornerstones of this nation. Not only did this case simply gave women their right to have an abortion or not, it was a stepping stone for other liberal proposals.
Obviously, the choice should be available to mothers if their lives are in danger. However, the state argues against this choice because certain states are generally geared toward one end of the political party spectrum. They want to maintain their ideals in the courts as well as hold down state values that have long prospered in that particular state.
Roe v. Wade has to be one of the cornerstones of this nation. Not only did this case simply gave women their right to have an abortion or not, it was a stepping stone for other liberal proposals.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)